The Common Good Index of National Division Fall 2024

A Nation Fractured: Dwindling Patriotism adding to Growing Division?  

HIGHLIGHTS

PATRIOTISM

A majority of Americans (66%) believe that people are generally less patriotic than in the past. Nearly half (48%) see this as a contributing factor to the nation’s growing divisions. 39% of Americans define patriotism as ‘love of country’, while 23% emphasized ‘advocating for reform and change.’

A PATH FORWARD

When asked which presidential candidate is more likely to reduce national division, 46% of Americans believe Kamala Harris would be most effective, while 32% favor Donald Trump. Additionally, 16% believe neither candidate would help.

CIVILITY & COMPROMISE

A stunning 86% of Americans believe it's possible to disagree about politics respectfully, and 63% think compromise is more important in a politician than standing firm to support principles. This emphasis on compromise and civility may be an encouraging sign for reducing national division and uniting Americans, which 55% say
is a responsibility that falls equally
upon citizens, elected officials, and the media.

THE ENEMY WITHIN

The survey reveals that 73% fear the greatest threat to America is internal rather than external. 72% fear that national division directly threatens democracy.

EFFECTIVENESS OF GOVERNMENT

While 76% of Americans agree that civility is necessary for a healthy democracy, the survey highlights a troubling reality: more than half of Americans (63%) believe the government is so divided it is no longer effective, and an equal percentage are somewhat or outright dissatisfied with the government’s performance.